(386) 668-9199

Award-Winning,
Authentic New York Style
Pizzeria and Italian Restaurant

(386) 668-9199 or email caitlin@goodfellasitalianrestaurant.com


Prices may vary according to quantity ordered. This menu is not exclusive to our catering selections. Please see our dinner menu for other food selections and we will be happy to accommodate your request.



Option 1: Combinations

(10 person minimum)

Choose from one of our four convenient catering combos below for quick and easy menu planning. Each Combination includes choice of salad, bread, and one (1) entrée.

  • ($10.95 per person)
  • ($11.95 per person)
  • ($12.95 per person)
  • ($13.95 per person)



Option 2: A la Carte

Create a custom menu from our a la carte tray offerings. Half- and full-pan options available for salad and entrées.

  • Half pan serves approximately 10 people | Full pan serves approximately 20 people
  • Add chicken to any pasta half pan for $15.00 | Full pan for $30.00
    Add shrimp to any pasta half pan for $30.00 | Full pan for $60.00
  • Whole wheat penne pasta substitution available
  • Please inquire about our selection of desserts available!